Why is my tide height negative?
A thread on the Yachting Monthly forum is titled "Chart Datum and negative tidal heights".[1] The question behind it has two parts: how a tide height can be below zero, and why two sources give different heights for the same tide. Both come down to where the height is measured from.
A height is measured from somewhere
A tide table says "3.2 m". Above what? The answer is the datum, and there are several in use.
Mean sea level is, in NOAA's definition, the arithmetic mean of hourly heights observed over a 19-year period.[2] A height measured from an average level is below zero whenever the water is below that average.
Charts and tide tables are meant to share a level. The International Hydrographic Organization resolves that tide predictions for mariners use the same datum as the chart, and that this chart datum should be Lowest Astronomical Tide (LAT), or a level as close to it as a hydrographic office finds practical.[3] LAT is the lowest level that can be expected under average weather conditions and any combination of astronomical conditions.[4] In the United Kingdom, the National Tidal and Sea Level Facility describes chart datum as approximately the lowest level due to astronomical effects, and tidal levels are given as heights above it.[5]
NOAA also defines Mean Lower Low Water (MLLW): the average of the lower low water of each tidal day over the same 19-year period.[2] Because it is an average of low waters, some low waters are below it, and a height measured from it can be negative.
How far apart the levels are
Our tide heights are relative to mean sea level unless you ask otherwise.
With datum=lat they are measured from LAT, which we work out at each point
by running the model over a 19-year cycle and taking the lowest value. The
IHO recommends a minimum of 19 years for this calculation.[3] This is
how far LAT sits below mean sea level at nine places:
| Place | LAT below mean sea level |
|---|---|
| Saint-Malo bay, France | 6.91 m |
| Bay of Fundy, Canada | 6.19 m |
| Off Darwin, Australia | 3.95 m |
| Dover Strait, England | 3.91 m |
| Brest approaches, France | 3.52 m |
| Gulf of Tonkin, Vietnam | 2.00 m |
| Off San Francisco, USA | 1.56 m |
| Off Sydney, Australia | 0.88 m |
| Off Honolulu, USA | 0.40 m |
So for the same water in the bay of Saint-Malo, a height from mean sea level and a height from LAT differ by almost seven metres. Off Honolulu they differ by 40 cm. If two sources disagree by the same amount at every high and low water, check whether they are using different datums.
In 2027 the lowest low water we predict off Brest is 13 cm above our LAT, and
in the bay of Saint-Malo 22 cm above. With datum=lat, none of our 2027
predictions at these nine points is negative.
Model datum and chart datum
Our LAT comes from a global tide model[6] and is not the official chart
datum of any port. The IHO resolution allows a hydrographic office to use
another level where low waters often deviate from LAT or where national
policy has set a different datum.[3] The API offers two datums, msl
and lat.
Our heights are astronomical predictions. NOAA says of its own predictions that it cannot predict the effect of wind, rain, freshwater runoff and other short-term meteorological events,[7] and ours leave those out too. The nine points above are in open water. On open coasts our comparison with NOAA's tide tables found the times within three to seven minutes. In a harbour or an estuary, use the local tables.
Getting heights from either level
curl -H "Authorization: Bearer $THIRDTRAIL_KEY" \
"https://thirdtrail.life/v1/tides/extremes/?lat=48.70&lon=-2.05&days=2&datum=lat"
Leave datum out for heights from mean sea level. datum=lat needs a paid
plan. The response's resolved.datum field says which level was used. Do not
navigate by these figures.
Sources
- Yachting Monthly forum (Scuttlebutt). "Chart Datum and negative tidal heights." https://forums.ybw.com/threads/chart-datum-and-negative-tidal-heights.461010/
- NOAA Center for Operational Oceanographic Products and Services. "Tidal Datums." https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/datum_options.html
- International Hydrographic Organization. "Resolutions of the IHO," Publication M-3, 2nd edition, updated October 2026. Resolution 3/1919 as amended, "Datums and Bench Marks." https://iho.int/en/miscellaneous-publications
- National Tidal and Sea Level Facility. "Definitions of tidal levels and other parameters." https://ntslf.org/tides/definitions
- National Tidal and Sea Level Facility. "Chart datum and ordnance datum." https://ntslf.org/tides/datum
- AVISO+, CNES. "FES2022 (Finite Element Solution) Ocean Tide." https://www.aviso.altimetry.fr/en/data/products/auxiliary-products/global-tide-fes/release-fes22.html
- NOAA Center for Operational Oceanographic Products and Services. "Frequently Asked Questions." https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/faq.html
Method: predictions from the FES2022 global tide model using 34 constituents at each point. LAT is the minimum of a 19-year hourly prediction, refined to the minute. Lowest low waters are for 2027. The points are in open water near the places named, not in their harbours. Informational use only, not for navigation.